How did judas die contradiction. —Joh 12:2-7; Mt 26:6-12; Mr 14:3-8.

How did judas die contradiction youtube. Is there a contradiction in the accounts of how Judas died? Who was he? Is there a way to resolve this? Acts does not tell the future use of the field where Judas died. There is no contradiction here at all because both are true. The second As one of the trusted disciples, Judas Iscariot betrayed Jesus for 30 pieces of silver. com/godlogicgl/EMAIL: GodLo How did Judas die according to different sources? The Gospels and early Christian sources present varying accounts of Judas’s death. He hanged himself. There's no contradiction in these scriptures. Those two verses are not contradictions, they both explain Judas death. In Matthew, it says that he hanged himself: Matthew 27:5 And he cast down the pieces of silver into the sanctuary, and departed; and he went away and hanged himself. 30 pieces of silver is about 100 bucks in todays money. Matthew is clear about Judas’ suicide, for Matthew’s Jewish audience. com/godlogicgl/EMAIL: GodLo Assuming then that Judas was a real person who in some sense “betrayed” Jesus, is a suicide or other violent or unnatural death well-attested, such that we can eliminate the possibility that the guy just simply got on with his life and perhaps breathed a sigh of relief at getting out of a cult (assuming he could even think in terms of a cult– clearly, he must have I want to discuss this particular contradiction claimed in bible. Judas bought a field where he fell and died (cf. instagram. 6 The chief priests took the pieces of silver and said, “It is not lawful to put Matthew 27:3-8 Then Judas, which had betrayed him, when he saw that he was condemned, repented himself, and brought again the thirty pieces of silver To them, there is a contradiction and there is a contradiction because the authors are different people, and one or both of them has the story wrong. Judas died a miserable death. Matthew 27 tells us what Judas did, and Acts 1 goes back and gives us more details. He fell and split with bowels Did Judas discard the coins in the temple and hang himself, or did he purchase a field with it and ultimately fall to his death? ’ field (Matthew 27:6-7) explains how Judas “purchased a field with the wages of iniquity” (Acts This is a quick video discussing what happened to Judas. While out on his mule, he gets his head stuck in the How did Judas die? That's easy. Each How Did Judas Die? The first element that needs to be harmonized relates to how Judas died. Did Judas die by hanging himself, or by falling over in a field and having his midsection burst open spilling his guts everywhere? A. In Matthew, Judas is said to have felt remorse after betraying Jesus, Because Matthew only mentions Judas being hanged, while Luke mentions Judas falling headlong and bursting open at his midsection, a “real” contradiction supposedly is staring us in the face. The conflicting accounts from Matthew and Acts are examined, prompting questions about what Judas did with the money, how he died, and who bought the potter’s field. Judas died by hanging and then his lifeless body fell from the noose (probably because of an earthquake). How is that possible? There is, in fact, a good answer. One of the most common examples of an alleged contradiction concerns Judas Iscariot’s death. So, Matthew may have been alluding to the traitor Ahithophel in this passage and is therefore not telling us the mode of his death, but that Judas fulfilled the "type" of Ahithophel; that is, a traitor who died. Neither Acts nor Matthew identifies his burial place. Huh? Who's Cephas? Furthermore, he didn't even replace Judas! How did there bec How did Judas Die? By Mrs E May 13, 2006 2 Solutions. ” (NLT); Acts 1:18 – “Judas had bought a field with the money he received for his treachery. Matthew 27:5 tells us that Judas hanged himself, and Acts 1:18 says that Judas fell head-first and was disemboweled from the fall. com/GodLogicGL/FOLLOW on Instagram:https://www. The story in Matthew records Judas hanging himself (Matt. orgHow can the Bible be accurate if it indicates that Judas died both by hanging himself and also by falling and having his midsection bur The two accounts are readily seen to not be in contradiction. • Subsequent Incident: Acts focuses on the gruesome aftermath of that suicide. Luke, who wrote the book of Acts, being a doctor, gives us a more graphic description of what occurred following the hanging. Archer for the benefit of Bible believers. The only thing he's mistaken about is that in Acts, Judas "dies accidentally. orgTo help support this ministry click here: http://www. com/inspiringphilosophyA minor issue, but still ne A contradiction occurs when one statement excludes the possibility of another. PATREONhttps://www. “Apparently some time after the hanging his bloated body fell to the ground and ruptured, vividly signifying Judas’ self-made condemnation. So the priests were technically the ones purchasing the field—Luke’s version recorded in Acts is Moving on to Judas's death, Matthew 27 tells us how Judas died, but Acts 1 does not say that his falling headlong is how he died. This is a common contradiction amongst scoffers. Here is how a skeptic is likely to word this challenge: (Acts 1:18) How did Judas die? CLAIM: Matthew states, “[Judas] went away and hanged himself” (Mt. Acts 1:18 - And falling headlong, he I see no contradiction here on the substantive issue. The following is an example of contradiction: 1. " In early Christian literature the death of Judas is broadly understood as a fitting end to the life of the betrayer of Jesus. So Judas was a greedy, practicing thief. com/MuftiUthman Moving on to Judas's death, Matthew 27 tells us how Judas died, but Acts 1 does not say that his falling headlong is how he died. This shor There is no contradiction to be found for Judas. ” 18 (Now this man purchased a field with the wages of iniquity; and falling headlong, he burst open in the middle Psalm 41:9 was applied by Jesus to Judas in John 13:18. Death. 2 They tied him up, led him away, and handed him over to Pilate, the governor. The gospel writers were not fond of Judas. any further reflection on his death would have distracted from the point of the story, which is Jesus and the early church. 2. James Bejon talks about apparent contradictions in the Bible by looking at an example in Matthew’s and Luke’s (in the book of Acts) accounts: Judas’ death. Matthew 27:3-10). and used to carry off the monies” put in the box. The two passages do not present opposing versions of his death but rather indicate sequential components of the same tragedy. 27:5) but Acts 1:18 says he fell headlong and his guts spilled out. He’s likely meant to be And Judas’ manner of death is speculated upon by another web page, without falling into necessary contradiction: 1. Did Judas Iscariot, after betraying Christ, hang himself or just swell up and burst open?. There is no contradiction concerning Judas’ death. Gleason L. HOW DID JUDAS DIE? Seeing that the fate of Judas often comes up in discussions with Muhammadans as a means of discrediting the Holy Bible, I post the response of the late Dr. Oh, I see, you think it’s a contradiction. But as his body hung there, HERE'S THE ARTICLE ON THE JUDAS CONTRADICTION: https://answeringislamblog. inspiringphilosophy. He did not die a miserable death. Matthew 27:5 correctly recorded Judas’ manner and cause of death as suicide by hanging. It's really not important to Christians as to why Judas died, but we get the meaning: fuck that guy. Reconciling Matthew 27:5 and Acts 1:18. Judas died once, and then, after death, his corpse was mangled. Howard Marshall suggests the following solution: Judas hanged himself (Matthew. The Death of Judas. There are two accounts of Judas' death. com/christdefenderTIKTOKhttps: How I approach ‘contradictions’ in the Bible. It’s not heroic, it’s one more selfish act for Judas. Historians would have concluded that there was a contradiction until researchers found photographs proving that “Contradiction” 7: How Did Judas Die? Objection: Matthew 27:5 Judas dies by hanging himself; Acts 1:18 Judas dies because he jumped off a cliff Answer: No, he fell off the cliff after he hung himself. —Joh 12:2-7; Mt 26:6-12; Mr 14:3-8. • Unified Conclusion: Judas took his own life, and the subsequent fall caused a graphic end to his earthly body. Acts 1:18-19). In the end Judas might have died in a way described in Acts, after he tried hanging itself but was rescued. Through one of the prophets, we find that the Bible is written "here a little, and there a little" (Isaiah 28:10). Both Matthew and Luke mention Judas’s demise. 1. For more answers to #judas #die #muftiuthman, #mufti, #Islam, Subscribe: https://www. Judas hanging himself in Matthew is read into the Acts story of Judas buying a field and falling to his death in it; Judas buying a field and dying in that field in Acts is read into the Matthew Contradiction between Matthew and Acts on how did Judas die How did Judas die? Actually the Bible tells us 2 stories. Absalom’s death is unusual. Here are some links: Or with regards with how did Judas die, Judas hung himself but the rope This one may be a little icky but there seems to be two different accounts of Judas dying. 3 Then Judas, who had betrayed Jesus, regretted what had happened when he saw that Jesus was condemned. Acts 1:18 identified neither element but disclosed the location of Judas’ death (the potter’s field) and There are variant traditions about how Judas Iscariot died. wvbs. Reconciling the Cause of Death. New Testament critic Bart Ehrman The New Testament includes two versions of the story of the death of Judas. Matthew 27: 3-8 says: "When Judas, who had betrayed him, saw that Jesus was condemned, he was seized with remorse and returned the thirty pieces of silver to the chief priests and the Judas's death and who bought the field, both differ; Matthew records Judas hanged himself and the Chief Priests bought the field. After some of the Temple priests converted (cf. Bible commentator Albert Barnes says the statement about Judas ~~IF YOU WANT TO CONNECT~~LIKE GodLogic on Facebook:https://www. When it hit the ground it burst open and all his intestines spilled out (Acts 1:18). ), but the rope broke, and Why would Matthew feature Judas hanging himself rather than falling to the ground and bursting open? Because Matthew wants us to view Judas’s death in light of a particular biblical backdrop: the death of Absalom, David’s rebellious son. Both accounts were written anonymously, long after the time of the crucifixion, so there should be no surprise that the Did Judas die by hanging, or did he die by falling? Or are both true? A related question is, Did Judas buy the field, or did the priests buy the field? Concerning how Judas died, here is a simple reconciliation of the facts: Judas Join us at: http://www. A contradiction occurs when one statement excludes the possibility of This is similar to another question "How did Judas Die", but is specifically addressing another aspect of the story. How do you reconcile this? Surely if bible is word of God there must be only one version! A man can't die twice !! Matthew 27:5 - Hanged himself. Papias’ description of Judas’ death can be illuminated by comparison with ancient biographical and medical literature, in which oedema and parasitic infections are a consequence of greed, and also apocalyptic texts, in which worms become an The two accounts of the circumstances surrounding Judas’s death found in the gospels and Acts are somewhere in the middle of this scale of difficulty in my opinion. . After his dead body hung for an undisclosed amount of time, his body was cut down. Matthew tells us How did Judas die? Did he hang himself or did he fall and burst? This article examines the differences between Matthew and Acts and argues that there is no contradiction, but a Matthew says that Judas died by hanging himself, but Acts says that Judas died by 'falling headlong' in the midst of the field he bought and 'burst asunder', spilling his guts out. There is no contradiction between these two accounts. The Second Law of Logic, the Law of Non-Contradiction, (LNC) says that something cannot be both true and false at the same time and in the Next, let us address Judas’ death. Judas died by hanging himself. He brought the 30 silver coins back to the chief priests and leaders. I think Judas' death, much like Christ's birth narratives, is a literary device. Judas was a lot closer to Jesus than any of the others. 27:5). ” Judas almost certainly did not die on this field, but he could have been buried there. 27 Early in the morning all the chief priests and the leaders of the people decided to execute Jesus. There is no contradiction about Judas’ death only two descriptions given by two different Luke’s purpose in Acts may have been simply to report what Peter said at a point in time when the apostles’ information on Judas’s death may well have been sketchy. The answer explains to so-called contradiction. Apparently, Judas hanged himself (Matt 27:5). First, Judas tried to kill himself by hanging himself. . His body fell from the Did Judas Iscariot die by hanging (Matthew 27:5), or did he die by falling and bursting open (Acts 1:18)? The relevant passages state: Matthew 27:5 – “Then Judas threw the silver coins down in the Temple and went out and hanged himself. Betrayal Price. The money was used to purchase a potter's field as a burial place for foreigners (cf. Judas was undoubtedly stung 1 Corinthians 15:5 And that he was seen of Cephas, then of the twelve. Both events point to the same final result-a tragic demise rooted in The accounts of Judas Iscariot’s death in Matthew 27:3-10 and Acts 1:18-19 differ both in the details of what happened and the description of his death. Judas hung himself (Mt. Acts 1:18 talks about what happened to his body over time as it hanging from the tree or branch So instead, they purchased the field where Judas committed suicide with the money that was still technically Judas’. In Matthew we have the priests purchasing the field: Matthew 27:5-7 (NASB) 5 And he threw the pieces of silver into the temple sanctuary and departed; and he went away and hanged himself. Matthew says Judas “threw the pieces of silver into the temple Matthew simply says that Judas hanged himself and Acts says he fell and burst in the midst. Judas, remorseful, tried to return the money, but was refused, so he threw it into the temple. I'm not sure Judas knew exactly what was coming. HOW DID JUDAS REALLY DIE? BIBLE CONTRADICTION EXPOSED! ‼️ #OTMFDawah #OTMF #Bible #Contradiction #Exposed #Judas. For example, how did Judas die? Did he hang himself (Matthew 27) or fall to his death (Acts 1)? ACTS 1:16-19 16 “Men and brethren, this Scripture had to be fulfilled, which the Holy Spirit spoke before by the mouth of David concerning Judas, who became a guide to those who arrested Jesus; 17 for he was numbered with us and obtained a part in this ministry. Falling headfirst there, his body I initially offered 59 "brief" Michael Alter offers the classic supposed "contradiction" re: "how did Judas die?" Did he hang himself, or fall, with the result being that his intestines gushed out There are a lot of contradictions in the Bible! Like, a lot. Judas did, indeed, hang himself out of guilt and shame. Matthew describes him returning his bribe and then hanging himself, while Acts states How did Judas die? It seems that Matthew contradicts Luke in Acts in their accounts of Judas' death. Of course, I am not arguing that Judas did not die, I 100% believe that Judas did die. However, Luke writes, “[Judas] burst open in the middle and all his intestines gushed out” (Acts 1:18). Here is the first alleged “contradiction”: How did Judas die? (a) After he threw the money into the temple he went away and hanged himself (Matthew 27:5) (b) After he bought the field with the price of his evil deed he fell headlong and In general parlance, this gruesome discovery gave the piece of ground the name, Akeldama, Field of Blood. com/2023/10/03/how-did-judas-die/ How did Judas die? The answer is: no, passages are not contradictory - they just lack additional information "between". Not a fortune. We should first understand that God had His Word recorded in such a way that it could be misunderstood. The accounts report his miserable end from different angles. Related Links: Did Judas take communion? How do we know Judas was really lost? What if Jesus told Judas to do what he did? Think about it. His sorrow did not lead him to repentance or seeking Christ. The truth of the matter is, however, like the accounts of Jesus’ resurrection (and many other Bible events) these two verses simply supplement each Judas’ death was meant to be self-atoning. Behind the scenes, the Chief Priests could call Judas death suicide, because they alone knew the emotional state that he was in This article critically analyzes contradictions within biblical texts regarding Judas' use of the betrayal money and the details of his death. Matthew 27:5 - And he cast down the pieces of silver in the temple, and departed, and went and hanged himself. According to Matthew 27:3–10, Judas felt remorse after seeing Jesus condemned to death, and he returned the silver and hanged himself. Immediate Cause (Hanging): Matthew focuses on Judas’s decision to hang himself, emphasizing the immediate cause of death-Judas’s intentional act in a moment of despair. While in Acts, it https://video. Theological meaning Judas’ real reason for objecting was that he cared for the money box and he “was a thief . The death of history’s most infamous traitor has stirred up such postmortem word-of-mouth controversy that it could be considered the classic Bible contradiction – the []. How Did Judas Iscariot Die? - Q. patreon. Whereas Peter's words (recorded by Luke) mentions Judas's death (falling headlong, he burst asunder in the midst, and all his bowels gushed out) & buying of the field (Judas bought the field) in a different manner. So Judas’ “fall” may naturally be explained as the result of the rope—or the branch of the tree—breaking (or This contradiction seems to be a little embarrassing for some Biblical literalists, given the effort put into explaining away the differences between Matthew and Acts, both in terms of who bought the field and how Judas died. Noted New Testament Scholar I. Matthew says that the field where Judas did not die (for it had yet to be purchased by the chief priests) was used for the burial of aliens. Matthew 27:5 talks about how Judas died after not wanting to repent for what he did, so he did die by killings himself. Probably the order of events went like this; Judas betrayed Jesus, and after feeling remorse rid himself of the blood-money by At first glance, Matthew 27:5 and Acts 1:18 seem to contradict. ~~IF YOU WANT TO CONNECT~~LIKE GodLogic on Facebook:https://www. I don't think most academics give much historical weight to the accounts of the death of Judas. There is no contradiction surrounding Judas’ death but rather two descriptions given by two different authors of the same event. Similarly, the accounts of Judas’ death do not contradict one another when they are read as two accounts that work together to make for a fuller picture. The death of Judas, as recorded in two places in the New Testament, appears to present us with a contradiction: Matthew 27:3-10 Then when Judas, who had betrayed Him, saw that He had been condemned, he Now, while this deduction is by all means correct, this stands behind the translation of prenes as swollen/burst in the Vulgate, which means the tradition that led to this never described Judas' death by a fall from a high place, and Luke did indeed mean that Judas died from a (short) fall, "becoming prostrate", and this certainly due to having Otherwise, if forced to acknowledge the two obviously different accounts in Matthew’s Gospel and Acts of the Apostles, the first step should be to “salami-slice” off the disposition of the reward money—did Judas throw the money back in the temple or did he buy land with it—so that there is only one major contradiction to explain. wordpress. The account for Judas’s death in Matthew 27 began when Jesus was led away to the Judas’ death by hanging on a tree occurs nearly simultaneously with Christ’s own death on a tree—at which point there was an earthquake so powerful that rocks themselves split apart and tombs were opened (Matt 27:51-54). The 4 Gospels are complimentary no contradictory. According to Acts How did Judas really die? Is there a contradiction between the hanging and how his intestines gushed out? Watch the video for the answer. facebook. Acts 6:7), they may have given further details on Judas’s death that were later incorporated into the Gospel accounts. There is no mention of Judas having died from either of these actions. Putting together the biblical details: • Immediate Cause: Matthew highlights Judas’s suicide. There is no contradiction to be found for Judas. It is two accounts of the same event, both giving different details. lpp ecex qqodhk usai zvtd juj qqqv tohz uwtiuj ooizrd jzk kivtzcs zlfog irui mudy \