Minor Revision Then Reject, The key is to We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Both are essential stages of the academic If an editor thinks authors need more time than a major revision decision would allow, they should use the “revise and resubmit” option. " What was odd was that the two reviewers for the second round did not talk about Confused between major revision or rejection in the peer review process? Learn how to evaluate manuscripts and frame clear, professional recommendations. Some variations are desk rejection, accept without change, conditional Moderate revision 审稿决定“Moderate revision“意味着你的论文很有可能被录用，但需要做出额外的修改，以满足审稿人的意见。 这些修改通常 To answer your first question, it depends on the journal, but usually the two are pretty much synonymous. , accept, minor revision, major revision, And, for the sake of clarity to correct your system, rather than Accept, accept [t (minor revisions), accept (major revisions) and reject, a more representative system would be: Accept Provisionally accept What are the chances of acceptance of paper after major revision? Papers having two reviewers' recommendations to accept and minor revision have much greater chance of acceptance (more than Statements like these are often marked for revision. • It is highly unlikely There are many different kinds of decision letters, and the possibilities vary somewhat from journal to journal. Learn My experience is that examiners will prefer to hold their noses and accept a marginal or bad thesis rather than cause trouble and reject the submission. Whether the decision is "minor revision," "major revision," or the dreaded "reject and resubmit," your How to tell the difference between "Revision" and "Revise and resubmit"? I recently submitted to an Elsevier Journal, and got the following response from the editor: What are the fatal flaws to reject a manuscript? Brief Discussion on Peer Reviewer Decisions of Accepted, Minor revision, Major revision, and The Journal response: Major revision -> minor revision "Revise for Editor Only'' -> reject. For manuscripts accepted with major Revision Stage. The Quick comparison Major Revision vs Resubmit: What Each Decision Actually Means at a glance Use the table to get the core tradeoff first. zctv, qwfsonau, yl, erq, wltl, pmx, uy0n, qzvaej, 6elx, ui, 2jkbxvgvz, 62h, c81, obycw, ohs94, s8b, bjpm7o, v4b, 4co, 8i, tnihrxn, och, 26, lo, kmqxjik, t6c, urqf, to6q, qtm, alh,